81st Annual Academy Awards
34 Followers · 114 Items
Best Supporting Actress
Saved 2/21/09 to 81st Annual Academy Awards

#13/36 - Milk

I saw this film back in November just a few weeks after the election, so I was still in the politics mind set.

The film tells the story of Harvey Milk (Sean Penn), California’s first openly gay elected official, who after a life of struggling against oppression, is assassinated by a fellow politician, supervisor Dan White (Josh Brolin).

I loved this film and it really struck a chord with me, and I’m sure many fellow Californians as well, as one of Milk’s campaigns against a Prop so closely resembles that of the recent Prop 8. While Sean Penn is great, I think the supporting cast is ever better. James Franco, Josh Brolin, and Emile Hirsch are all fantastic as supporting cast. The only critique I’ve heard about this film is that the documentary is better. I’ve never seen it, so I really enjoyed it, but maybe if I had I’d feel differently. Either way, as much as I loved this film, I don’t predict it taking home any awards come Oscar night.


Best Picture
I just don’t think this film has generated enough buzz to really give Slumdog or The Reader a run for their money. But, it’s one of my favorites in the category, so I’m glad to see it here.

Best Director – Gus Van Sant
I’ve said before that whatever takes Picture will take Director as well, and I just don’t think Van Sant will take it home over Boyle.

Best Actor – Sean Penn
Penn is fantastic as Milk and a lot of people seem to think he’ll take this one home, but I’m standing by Mickey. He’s more deserving and everyone loves a good comeback.

Best Supporting Actor – John Brolin
This nomination seems to be nominating his recent career choices than the actual role. He didn’t get any recognition for No Country and I hear that he was the only reason to watch W. Brolin followed all that up with a great supporting performance in Milk and here he is. Personally, I think Franco has the most stand out performance next to Penn, but either way no one’s taking this award from Ledger.

Best Original Screenplay
This, I think, is it's best chance to take an award home for the night. The problem is that this category is just so unique. Recently there's always been a breakout winner (Juno, Little Miss Sunshine), but this year I loved all the entries. However, Milk has the most nominations out of all the films in this category, so it does stand apart from the rest in that regard.

Best Editing
This is a good entry here, but I just don’t think it has enough to cut it against the beautifully cut Slumdog.

Best Costumes
This is an interesting nomination, but I don’t think that the dated clothing will be enough to take home the win as the Academy tends to favors lavish costumes such as those in The Duchess.

Best Score
I wish I could recall a single note of the score, but it just didn’t seem memorable enough to me. Those that I remember, such as Changeling and Revolutionary Road, didn’t get nominated. My score radar was definitely a tad off this year. Either way, I think that Slumdog will take this home on Sunday.

Phasekitty Phasekitty 7 years 13 weeks
Whoops! :misinformed: You're totally right, and I think you're right about it winning too! Although I really like In Bruges as a dark horse in that category...that's the one category that I still haven't decided on a winner in yet.
kscincotta kscincotta 7 years 13 weeks
I absolutely loved this movie and I think your analysis is spot on. After seeing this movie, I spent the entire next day reading about Harvey Milk, someone I didn't know much about going in. While I think Sean Penn was very good in this role, I don't think he was great. I felt that his mannerisms were a bit inconsistent. Mickey was definitely better and I hope he wins. That said, the supporting cast, none of whom tend to be my favorites in films, were all phenomenal. James Franco and Emile Hirsch were both fantastic and really made the film for me. FYI, I'm pretty sure that this film wasn't directly based on the documentary or the book that the doc was based on. In fact, this film is nominated for Original Screenplay, not Adapted which I'm really hoping that it wins. It's only real competition there is Wall-E, I think.
WhatTheFrockBlog WhatTheFrockBlog 7 years 13 weeks
This and Slumdog are probably tied for my second favorite movie of the year (after the Wrestler). I thought it was just fantastic. I want Mickey Rourke to win but I think Sean Penn may walk away with the Oscar. Either one of them would deserve it.