The Mommy Club
2K Followers · 6.3K Items
Hot Ginger Caramel Martini
Saved 4/15/10 to The Mommy Club daughter's school is combining grades K-2

My daughter's currently in a catholic pre-school.  We had planned to send her there for kindergarten in September but now I just don't know.  They are in a very difficult financial situation and just told 3 teachers they will not be returning this fall.  The plan to keep the school open, which is grades Pre-K - grade 8, is to combine K-2 and 3-5. They plan to do this with 1 teacher and an aide, for K-2.   I'm very concerned that she will be left behind and not get the attention that she needs.  The principal is trying to assure parents that what they are trying to do is similiar to the Montessori program, which works similiar to this.  Problem is Montessori teachers are specially trained, and in our school they will be winging it.

While I'd hate to see a school close, I feel like I should get out now and start fresh at a new school.  Problem is most public and private schools had their registration in Feb and March.  Am I crazy or does this plan for combining grades actually seem like it would be beneficial?

Saved to

The Mommy Club

Hot Ginger Caramel Martini Spare the Hammer but not the Wrench Bookshelf Elephant Lemon Don't Punish Yourself When Giving Your Child Consequences Lessons to Teach Children Disciplining Children My daughter needs birth control!
Bettye-Wayne Bettye-Wayne 6 years 2 weeks
Absolutely, darling.
GregS GregS 6 years 2 weeks
I was in a combined 4-5 and I turned out OK. Right Betty? Don't forget that at one point in the not too distant past, this country had one room school houses that taught K-12. It all depends upon the teacher and their support network (that'd include the parents). Actually all education must include the parents every night.
Bettye-Wayne Bettye-Wayne 6 years 5 weeks
I guess I'm a little late to comment, since you've already decided to look for a new school.... all I was going to add is: if you are worried about her not getting enough attention in school, just do more with her at home. There are tons of teacher workbooks that you could use with your kids.
jenni5 jenni5 6 years 5 weeks
Thanks all, I needed a few more opinions! I'm going to start looking into new schools this week. If the teachers were going to be trained to handle this it might be a good thing but I feel like it's going to be a big mess and the school will end up closing anyway.
MissSushi MissSushi 6 years 6 weeks
I was in a couple schools that did this, and while it worked for me... I probably wouldn't do it with my kids. It was only good for me because I was bored with my own grade, and they were having us all do the same stuff - at the higher grade level. I loved it, but a lot of my peers REALLY struggled, and the teachers were really vague about a lot of things... I would personally probably find a different school, 3 grades seems ridiculous and way too chaotic and crowded. There is such a gap between those ages too. I dont agree with what the teachers are telling you either - its a totally different situation because there will probably be a LOT more students per teacher then a mont school. You cant just let teachers go and shove everyone in a big class and expect it to work flawlessly.
saneish-mom saneish-mom 6 years 6 weeks
My son's school did that when he was in K and now he is in 7th gr. And I will say it was wonderful. He was able to learn subjects not just his grade level but the other grades too. He is an A student and has been since K, he finds school easy ( even in the Advanced classes) What I liked was he stayed with the teachers and class mate too. It was new for his school to try it and he was very lucky to be part of it. I think if he was in the other class rooms, he wouldn't have done so well.
gigimama gigimama 6 years 6 weeks
My children attend a combined-grade K-8 charter school, and I love it. For example, this allows for a kindergartner who is reading at a first grade level to be put with academic peers regardless of what age he or she is. Age is not an indication of ability. I'm all for combined classrooms because there is more flexibility. If anything, your child will not be left behind but will benefit from being around the somewhat older children. She may enjoy the challenge. Older kids enjoy being "mentors" of sorts to the younger kids, who are anxious to do well. Plus, kids in combined classrooms often stay with the same classmates and teacher for several years, allowing for deeper relationships. It's cool. I'd be very upset if my kids' school decided to have single-grade classes.
AZarate AZarate 6 years 6 weeks
GET HER OUT NOW!! My niece is in a combined grade and it is horrible. She is learning 2nd grade work all over. The teacher claims she is giving her 3rd grade work but I remember these projects form last year. I have been trying to make them harder on our side but she finishes her homework so fast. We have decided to transfer her to a school where she will be challenged and in a class with only her grade.
runningesq runningesq 6 years 6 weeks
The plan to keep the school open which is grades Pre-K to grade 8 and combine K through 2 and 3 through 5 THREE grades in one classroom (k, 1, 2, and 3, 4, 5) sounds problematic to me.
B-mama-nyc B-mama-nyc 6 years 6 weeks
My apologies, I just went back and re-read... K-2 ;)
B-mama-nyc B-mama-nyc 6 years 6 weeks
Hey Jennibeans - I work in a K/1 classroom now and differentiating towards the different ages is difficult in itself so I can't imagine how much they would have to do to plan for a K-3 classroom. Have you spoken to the administration about the teachers plans to prepare for this new situation? How many students will be in the classroom? How many adults? There are numerous benefits to multi-grade classrooms, but you want to make sure that your daughters teachers are well prepared to be taking on such a task and that the appropriate supports will be provided. What about an educational enrichment program to supplement your daughters schooling?