Jane Austen Fans Unite!
34 Followers · 35 Items
BBC: Persuasion vs. S&S
Saved 4/04/08 to Jane Austen Fans Unite!

Which Mr. Darcy is hotter?


Colin Firth OR Matthew Macfadyen?

silver3zg silver3zg 3 years 27 weeks
Definitely, Colin! No doubt, Colin! I like his hair (dyed hair :)), I like his wet shirt, I like his coat, I like his eyes (deep eyes), I like his struggle with his emotion, I like everything on him. I like him. He is born to be Mr. Darcy. There is no other Mr. Darcy.
nikiandrea16 nikiandrea16 3 years 30 weeks
I totally loved Matthew as Darcy!! His eyes are just sooo gorgeous!!! N the scenes from the dawn and rain totally melted me! But no one can beat Colin... I just fall in love with him everytime he´s on screen... so I voted for Colin! <3
jhilly123 jhilly123 4 years 19 weeks
Matthew!! I totally love Colin Firth (Love Actually and Bridget Jones), but in this film he was so stiff (even if Darcy's supposed to be a bit arrogant and cold), but Matthew, he was fantastic and I listened to the Director's Cut and I noticed every little detail that Matthew did, and I love his version! he does everything so simply and is so gorgeous. The dawn scene is great, but I loved the rain scene the best.
Gimhong Gimhong 4 years 26 weeks
Matthew ,,of course :}
ophelie ophelie 5 years 44 weeks
I've only inscribed myself to write a comment on "Colin or Matthew" and i will write in the name of all French females : MATTHEW He's definitely so sexy in this movie!I've just seen him in this version and i will try to see more about him in other films.
elle86 elle86 5 years 50 weeks
good point hookedonmonix. and i cant believe matthew is ahead over 300 votes! cah-razy!!!!
hookedonmonix hookedonmonix 6 years 7 weeks
I wonder if it all depends on which you saw first. I've only seen Matthew, and I'm now madly in love with him, so I don't even want to see anyone else try to be mr. Darcy. The matthew at dawn moment was heart-thumping, but I was equally (if not more) taken away by the proposal/fight/serious romantic tension moment. sigh. mr darcy. how I love you.
hookedonmonix hookedonmonix 6 years 7 weeks
I wonder if it all depends on which you saw first. I've only seen Matthew, and I'm now madly in love with him, so I don't even want to see anyone else try to be mr. Darcy. The matthew at dawn moment was heart-thumping, but I was equally (if not more) taken away by the proposal/fight/serious romantic tension moment. sigh. mr darcy. how I love you.
elle86 elle86 6 years 9 weeks
wow matthew is super far ahead! 200 votes! crazy :):)
Raachel Raachel 6 years 11 weeks
Colin is better lookin .. only by a bit though. But i think matthew made the character his own more and gave Mr Darcy more emotion throught the film. So for that reason its matthew !! Sorry colin ur still hot though!
nancymae nancymae 6 years 16 weeks
There is no one who compares to COLIN. He is God's greatest GIFT too ALL women.
lala2002 lala2002 6 years 22 weeks
Mummmmmmm, Matthew. He's Mr Darcy in my mind. Probably because I seen the 2005 version before the 95. So when I read anything P & P I see Matthew. I think he's hotter in a different way than Colin. Don't get me wrong there is something attractive to me when it comes to Colin too! LOL.
mizlynz mizlynz 6 years 23 weeks
Colin! "Showtime, our love's comin' out. Lights, camera, action...show what we're about."
XxCoolBritannaxX XxCoolBritannaxX 6 years 23 weeks
I actually voted for Matthew, but I think it was because I just saw the movie "Circle of Friends" with Minnie Driver and also Colin Firth and he played a jerk so...my mind still on that. I'm afraid I'm tainted.
outofhere outofhere 6 years 23 weeks
Well, no worries db, I can clearly see that "Team Matthew" is not going to win the race. But, but......come on, Matthew walking through the mist, open shirt, restless from no sleep, coat swirling behind him.... :faint: my goodness, it just doesn't get much better! You Colin girls have definitely seen the Matthew one right? Right? I just have to make sure :)
Jasi Jasi 6 years 23 weeks
deeeeefinitely colin. mmmmmm, he's dreamy.
ShePirate2010 ShePirate2010 6 years 23 weeks
Matthew......yay
elle86 elle86 6 years 23 weeks
Maybe we should call a tie -- I mean, they both wear those AWESOMELY TIGHT British pants!!! SHA-zam! ;) (Matthew has more puppy dog eyes at points, and Colin's sparkle more.... so it really is a genuine toss-up).
desertbanshee desertbanshee 6 years 23 weeks
I wondered about that off part, Oxy. So glad it was a boo-boo. My dearest Le E, Let's have this out right here and now. Colin in the pond. Although, I will concede you this: Matthew, at dawn, in the fabulous billowing duster coat, sunrise WITH mysterious mist is truly call-the-fire-department hot. Smokin' But, I still got to go with the jump in the pond, bodily clinging wet shirt, and "Miss Elizabeth!?" encounter as the winner. Whew, it's hot in here! ;)
Oxymoron1 Oxymoron1 6 years 23 weeks
when I wrote it.
Oxymoron1 Oxymoron1 6 years 23 weeks
Ohh, I have just realized that obviously I Darcy turns me on... not off... I guess I was thinking of William Collins :ROTFL:
outofhere outofhere 6 years 23 weeks
Obviously us Matthew girls are in the minority here ;)
Oxymoron1 Oxymoron1 6 years 23 weeks
I voted for Colin, but I have to recognize that the character of Mr. Darcy turns me off. I wish I were Elizabeth Bennet!!!!
outofhere outofhere 6 years 23 weeks
Oh, my dearest db, I'm going to have to dispute you on that ;) Colin at the pond surely makes my knees go weak, but Matthew at dawn? That has become my all time most swoon worthy moment in cinematic history. I voted for Matthew, just in case it wasn't obvious ;)
desertbanshee desertbanshee 6 years 24 weeks
Colin! No one tops the pond scene, not even Matthew at dawn.